AWARD Google Ads Impact Award 2026:
smec wins International Growth for taking All4Golf into 19 new markets.

The online retail growth podcast with
Mike Ryan & Christian Scharmüller

Shein Is Gone, Temu Is Back: Who You’re Bidding Against This Q4

Released:

Shein has gone quiet in Google Ads, Temu is back, and a low-cost marketplace called Joom is surging. Here’s who you’re bidding against this peak season.

Mike Ryan and Chris Scharmueller look at what changed in Chinese commerce advertising since the EU’s new €3 per-item duty on low-value parcels took effect in July. The good news: there’s less pressure in the auction than last year. The catch: who’s left.

In smec’s advertiser panel, Temu showed up as a competitor for about three quarters of advertisers before the tariffs, dropped to around a third, and is now back to about half. Shein has been winding down its ads since spring and is close to gone. The surprise is Joom: up from about 10% of advertisers to roughly a third, and two thirds in fashion and lifestyle, despite paying the same tariffs. Why it keeps spending is an open question.

Then the shops that don’t exist: fake heritage brands. A local-sounding name, a founding year, AI-generated founders standing in a Berlin store, and a €6 shirt from China sold for €60, “marked down” from €110. The markup is so high the tariff barely touches them. The hosts found hundreds of these in Google Ads data, and they’ve taken a share of Shein’s place in the auction.

The hosts also compare what shoppers see at checkout on each site, and explain why Shein’s next half-year results could show the full damage.

First, two Google updates: a push to make AI Mode results shareable, one more step away from retailers’ own websites, and reports that Google is feeding scrapers and rank trackers shuffled, “poisoned” search results. Want to keep an eye on this through Black Friday? smec Market Observer tracks the Shopping impression share of Amazon, Temu, eBay, AliExpress and other big players in European Google Shopping, week by week.

⏱ Timestamps 00:00 - Google updates, Chinese commerce and a new player

01:03 - Google wants to make AI Mode results shareable

05:25 - Google is poisoning the SERP for scrapers

09:55 - Peak season: who’s back in your auctions?

12:48 - Temu bounces back, Joom triples

14:34 - Why Shein went quiet, and why its next results matter

19:58 - Fake heritage brands: the shops that don’t exist

24:48 - Checkout compared: Shein, Temu, Joom and fake heritage

💡 Key Takeaways Overall, competitive pressure from Chinese commerce players in Google Shopping is lower than last year, a net benefit for advertisers going into peak season. The mix of who’s left has changed.

Since 1 July 2026, the EU charges a flat €3 customs duty per item on parcels worth under €150. Some countries add their own handling fees on top.

Temu’s comeback: in smec’s advertiser panel it went from about 75% of advertisers before the tariffs, to around a third straight after, and back to about half now.

Shein has been winding down its ads since March, with a sharp drop in June, and is now close to absent. Its first-half 2026 revenue grew just 1% and adjusted operating profit halved. The hosts expect the second-half results to show the full effect of the European ad pullback.

Joom is the new player: up from about 10% of advertisers to roughly a third, and about two thirds in fashion and lifestyle, where Shein used to be most active.

At checkout, Shein and Joom show the tariff in full. Temu has started offering a discount on the tariff to protect its conversion rate. Fake heritage shops don’t show it at all.

Fake heritage brands are the hardest to fight: AI-generated founder photos, fake markdowns, pushes to buy multiples (the duty is charged per item), fake urgency, and delivery that takes around ten days because the goods ship from China.

Rank trackers report “poisoned” Google results since 20 September: up to 25% of results at peak and 5–11% per day since October. Ads and shopping results look unaffected so far. Google hasn’t commented.

Episode Highlight

The Impact of Fake Heritage Brands As European tariffs force major Chinese e-commerce players like Shein to scale back advertising, a new wave of deceptive ""fake heritage"" brands has stepped in to fill the void. These storefronts present themselves as long-standing local businesses using AI-generated backstories and images, while secretly dropshipping low-cost items from China at massive markups. Because their profit margins are so artificially inflated, these storefronts can easily absorb tariff costs that disrupt legitimate retailers. For e-commerce leaders, recognizing this tactic is essential as these bad actors drive up ad costs and distort auction dynamics across Google Ads.

  • Mike Ryan“What they do is they’ll dropship a €6 shirt from China, put it on their website for €60, say that it’s marked down from €110, and there’s no mention of the tariff because their markup is so high that they can just eat it.​”

Episode Transcript

​​ 00:00:00 - 00:00:24

Mike: Welcome to another episode of Growing Ecommerce. Today, we’re going to give you a couple of brief updates about more changes to Google Search as AI continues to unfold, and then we’ll get into an update on Chinese commerce: Shein, Temu, fake heritage brands, and a new player—a new kid on the block. I’m sorry, almost forgot a new kid on the block.

00:00:24 - 00:00:45

Mike: The new Temu, the Temu version of Temu, let’s call it.

Chris: Hello, sir. How about me?

Mike: Hey Chris, I see you—and all of you out there. I’m Mike Ryan, by the way. Are you wearing… You’re wearing a smec hoodie. Wow!

Chris: Yes, do you like it?

Mike: Yes! That’s what I see every single week. That looks way newer…

00:00:45 - 00:01:03

Mike: …way newer and cleaner than mine.

Chris: Yeah, maybe I should get it, but this was the last one that fitted because we only have 3XL left. This is an S. Now, in case you wonder why I’m looking so sharp.

Mike: Yeah, I know. S! We know you purposely wear the smaller sizes, Chris.

00:01:03 - 00:01:28

Chris: Yes. So, not always about that, but most of the time. All right, you start with the brief updates.

Mike: All right, so just a couple of quick things that caught our attention. You know, I think it’s very interesting to see behind the scenes of what Google’s doing. We saw a patent from a while back that they might try to dynamically generate landing pages in the future.

00:01:28 - 00:01:53

Mike: These are a couple of little things coming from behind the veil a bit. I read online that Google has a new product manager role open, and it’s focused on AI sharing capabilities. What this is: right now, you can share links from Google, Google Discover, wherever you can easily share links.

00:01:53 - 00:02:20

Mike: And when you do, from the Google app, it will have this shared Google domain that they use, and that is their sharing product as it exists right now. It’s all about links and sending traffic around the web. But what they’re interested in is having an equivalent kind of experience for other services like AI Overviews and AI Mode, which right now—it makes a lot of sense—are hard or impossible to share.

Chris: Yeah.

00:02:20 - 00:02:39

Mike: These things are dynamic on the fly, and that’s what the PM will be working on. So for the open web and for people’s site traffic, this is not necessarily good.

Chris: Nope.

Mike: It’s also…

00:02:39 - 00:03:03

Chris: They want this to be persistent, more or less. So imagine—let me put an e-commerce use case on it: you are browsing or using AI as an assistant for product recommendations for some Christmas gifts for the kids. When you want to share with your wife, you can say, “Oh, I got this good set, but now I would like her to look at it.” So you can now share that over.

00:03:03 - 00:03:26

Chris: And she can say, “I really like that, but the price is too high on this one.” And then you can get a notification when the price drops—Google can do that. And so this will now also be stateful, as it’s called—this persistent thing. You can wait for the price to drop, and then you could visit the retailer or maybe use Universal Cart, you never know.

00:03:26 - 00:03:45

Chris: By the way, do you have any timeline when this thing will be live in Europe?

Mike: I don’t know. I mean, I’d like to think—or I have mixed feelings about it—but I’d like to think sooner rather than later, because they need to compete against Perplexity and other offerings. Peak season? I would doubt it.

00:03:45 - 00:04:01

Mike: I just, when I see stuff like what’s going on in CSS right now—we can talk about that in a bit, it continues to be a topic—I’m like, is CSS going to be a topic in AI, too? Like what’s going to happen? A lot of questions. I think there’s so much for them to work out.

00:04:01 - 00:04:27

Chris: Yeah, not a lot to add from my side. I think this makes sense end-to-end.

Mike: Yeah, I think if it buys into the vision of Universal Cart, this is, depending on your business model, not good for you. Because rather than sharing a cart that was built or a wishlist that was built on your website, this is a competing alternative to that, for sure.

00:04:27 - 00:04:46

Mike: And it’s not great, but it’s interesting to watch. I think there will be e-commerce implications.

Chris: But maybe just one thing: this is the direction Google is moving towards.

00:04:46 - 00:05:09

Chris: It’s certainly not putting your website—whether you’re a brand or an online retailer—into the center of their decision-making. Because again, I can’t remember how many times I shared a basket with my wife.

Mike: Yes.

Chris: Literally, this is now just one step before you even enter the website.

00:05:09 - 00:05:25

Chris: These little things will add up at some point, I’m really sure about that. It’s the same: we’re always sharing baskets and she’s never logged in, so then she shares a link to a cart and there’s nothing in it. By the way, it’s a pain. So this will be adopted, for sure, because it has massive advantages. I can imagine that.

00:05:25 - 00:05:53

Chris: So, something to watch.

Mike: Another thing: evil Google!

Chris: Well, you know what? They’re taking defensive action. Google is poisoning the SERP deliberately.

Mike: Yes, deliberately poisoning the SERP.

Chris: That should be the headline for this episode.

00:05:53 - 00:06:17

Mike: It sounds big! If you’re in the SEO community, this is big. We don’t usually talk too much about SEO topics, but we think that this could also have implications for e-commerce in the future. What’s happening is that there are all kinds of scrapers out there scraping Google.

00:06:17 - 00:06:42

Mike: They scrape it for AI Overviews, they scrape it for organic rankings, and there are also AI models scraping Google as an information layer to help their model evaluate sources. ChatGPT has been mass-scraping Google—they’ve been mass-scraping Shopping as well. They’ve stopped that in the US, but still do it in Europe.

00:06:42 - 00:07:05

Chris: They still do in Europe, yes.

Mike: And there’s even the chance that people could scrape Google and try to distill their ranking out of there. So what Google is doing is, if they detect that you are a scraper, there’s a chance that they’re going to serve you a poisoned SERP. This means that they will just arbitrarily shuffle the order of the results.

00:07:05 - 00:07:30

Mike: It looks like a totally realistic SERP, but it’s not. The data is bad. It is not actually ranked according to Google’s ranking methods.

Chris: So you ordered fish, it looks like fish, but it’s not fish.

Mike: Exactly.

Chris: Honestly, I’m a simple man. I think it’s so simple for Google.

00:07:30 - 00:07:56

Chris: I don’t know about the detection part—how to detect whether you’re a scraper or not—but this is simple and fun. I think it will be effective.

Mike: It’s kind of this reverse Robin Hood thing. You think of stealing from the rich and giving to the poor, which is the mentality behind scraping Google in some use cases, and this is the opposite of that.

00:07:56 - 00:08:23

Mike: But on the other hand, at a gut level, I have to admit I find it clever and satisfying.

Chris: Clever, easy, and justifiable.

Mike: Yeah, you know, there are competitors, of course, and Google doesn’t owe these competitors anything. I understand there’s also this whole other industry built on it with SEMrush and whoever.

00:08:23 - 00:08:45

Chris: And by the way, SEMrush is a great company. I think we know each other, and I think there will be some deals made behind the curtain. If you’re big enough and you provide neutral data analysis like SEMrush, I think Google will be quite open.

00:08:45 - 00:09:08

Chris: Are they competing against Google Search Console or something? Maybe, but I think it’s a different use case. They want to help people invest in Google.

Mike: Yeah, I think it’s positive, and it’s not necessarily smart for Google to isolate those people. Google is smart and SEMrush is smart.

00:09:08 - 00:09:33

Chris: Since SEMrush is owned by Adobe now, right? By the way, they’re big.

Mike: Yeah.

Chris: So I think they will be more selective with it. Bottom line: I fully understand the move by Google. It’s not much of a surprise that it’s happening now with all the scraping going on.

Mike: Yeah, fed up with scrapers long enough.

00:09:33 - 00:09:55

Mike: And in the future, what if they start poisoning Shopping results? You never know. Serving fake Shopping results to bots! Anyhow, two cool news items. But the big one is actually…

Chris: Yeah, you’re not Mr. T anymore. I know you don’t like it.

Mike: Mr. Temu, yes.

00:09:55 - 00:10:20

Mike: But we still talk about Temu! I have to check in once in a while to see what’s going on.

Chris: You have to do some brand building.

Mike: Well, you know what happened, Chris? We’re in this peak season now, and I wanted to help our clients understand: what is the difference in these Chinese commerce players this year compared to last year?

00:10:20 - 00:10:49

Mike: So that they can understand. My overall finding is that there is less competitive pressure, and this is overall a net benefit that these advertisers are not as active anymore.

Chris: By the way, I think that’s absolutely right. It’s the right time to look into this because, let’s face it, even for these Chinese players which seem to have very deep pockets, Q4 is the quarter of the year.

00:10:50 - 00:11:13

Chris: And of course, if there’s any quarter of the year where they might be way more aggressive, even if it means burning money, it is Q4. So I think it’s cool. The numbers are super interesting. Let’s jump right into it.

Mike: Sure.

00:11:13 - 00:11:46

Mike: Because that was my general purpose, but then I was surprised by some of the things I found. I bungled it at the top, but I found this little company called Joom. Have you ever heard of Joom?

Chris: No, man.

Mike: I was aware that they exist only because of my line of work and looking at auction reports, but they were small fish. They still are, but they’re doing something very unusual, which is that they’re spending more money on ads now.

00:11:47 - 00:12:22

Mike: They’re continuing to ramp their ads, even though they are—to spell it out—one of these de minimis companies. They are sending cheap packages over the border. And of course, this got crushed earlier in the year by new tariffs in Europe. They don’t care. It’s insane.

Chris: It’s insane! By the way, I just did research: their business model is that they offer ultra low-cost umbrella general merchandise.

00:12:22 - 00:12:48

Chris: And the other fun thing is that they are not even this hypergrowth company. Growth expectations for this year are 5 to 10% on a 500 million annual revenue baseline. Which is—I mean, don’t get me wrong, it’s a significant company, but…

Mike: No, that’s why I’m wondering why and how can you afford to do this?

00:12:48 - 00:13:14

Mike: I couldn’t believe what I was seeing. If we look at our full advertiser panel, Temu—and we can put this on screen for viewers, too—was hitting about three-quarters of advertisers earlier this year before tariffs went in place.

00:13:14 - 00:13:36

Mike: That means they were showing up as an account-level competitor for about 75% of our advertiser panel. That dropped down to nearly a third in the immediate aftermath of the tariffs. But they’ve been finding a way. It’s like Jurassic Park: life will find a way. Temu, unfortunately, will find a way.

00:13:36 - 00:14:00

Mike: And they’re back up to about 50%, so they are also scaling. It’s crazy. What I didn’t expect to see is Joom as a new player. They were down at like 10% at the start of the year. There are these other models out there, little companies like LightInTheBox—I bet you never heard of them—they were back down to like 10%.

00:14:00 - 00:14:34

Mike: But instead of disappearing, Joom is now up to a third of advertisers, which is really surprising.

Chris: What’s also very surprising is their biggest market in Europe is Germany. They’re very big in Brazil internationally, but the EU seems to be an important market. The question is: when did they start to do the opposite of Temu and Shein this year?

00:14:34 - 00:14:59

Chris: What happens, because the margins are very thin, especially based on financial results from last year? It’s crazy.

Mike: It’s crazy. At first it made sense, because Shein was on their way toward an IPO and they knew that this type of thing was not looking good for them.

00:14:59 - 00:15:19

Mike: They’re publicly traded now in Hong Kong, but at the time, they reacted probably the most conservatively about the news of the tariffs. Back in March, they were already winding down their ads. There were also findings in France and other markets.

00:15:19 - 00:15:47

Mike: They’ve been winding down their ads since March, and then in June they had a dramatic drop. Based on our analysis, after about a month of tariff exposure, they turned their ads down even further. So Shein is gone for now.

Chris: Yeah, I assume that they are advertising maybe some local sellers from their marketplace, but their local seller marketplace never got that big.

00:15:47 - 00:16:15

Mike: We know Temu is also advertising local sellers in the US. Now, back to Joom: they started to rise in March/April or so, when Shein and Temu got softer. If we look specifically at this fashion and lifestyle brand cohort where Shein is most active…

00:16:15 - 00:16:43

Mike: …we see that’s also where Joom was most active and remains so. They started getting stronger and stronger in that area, and now they’re up to two-thirds of advertisers in that subset—like fashion and lifestyle—seeing competition from them. Beyond fashion, it’s roughly a third.

00:16:43 - 00:17:10

Mike: So actually, most of this growth in advertising pressure has occurred in fashion. It’s disproportionately there. But still, okay, I understand it was rational for them to take market share from Shein, but the tariffs hit and they just kept going.

Chris: They kept going. The only thing I could think of is because they are basically a marketplace model, right? That they have just awesome deals.

00:17:10 - 00:17:31

Chris: There has to be a margin driver for them, because talking about the new taxes, it won’t get better for these low-cost fashion providers. You will see some Western brands on there—you’ll see Adidas shoes and probably Nike.

00:17:31 - 00:17:57

Chris: But the bottom line is: Shein, they’re gone for good, which is great for local companies in Europe. Temu crawling back—not that big of a surprise, we talked about that. They have so much money, they’ll find an operating model that allows them to adapt. Joom is the new kid on the block. Let’s see how sustainable this is.

00:17:57 - 00:18:18

Mike: Yeah, and I think there’ll be a chance… We want to talk about one more player here—or group of players—but we can compare them at the end as well. The thing is, I just want to say about Shein: it’s going to be such a bloodbath, because they’re listed in Hong Kong and reporting standards are different.

00:18:18 - 00:18:42

Mike: They do not have to report every quarter; they report once every six months. Their last report only covered through June, and June is when their advertising dropped. But that was like one-third of one quarter, and they were reporting a whole six-month period. So I don’t think the market understands how bad this is yet.

00:18:42 - 00:18:58

Mike: The next period that they’re going to see at the end of the year or early next year is when they’re going to see what happened in Europe when all the ads were turned off for the whole six months.

Chris: It will fully materialize.

Mike: Yes, that’s a good way of putting it. It will materialize.

00:18:58 - 00:19:19

Chris: And let’s face it, Shein had a margin issue in the first place, right? If you’re operating at a net margin of 3% or slightly above 3%, and then you get this de minimis fee—what is it, €3 per product? And then there’s a new tariff landing.

00:19:19 - 00:19:42

Chris: Then we’re talking about €5 per product, actually, on clothes that only cost in some cases €6 to €10. If you look at comparison, in the Inditex group for instance, they are operating at a 50% margin plus.

00:19:42 - 00:20:10

Mike: So Shein, we will watch out for that earnings report. By the way, overall pressure dropped, and Zalando was a benefactor of Shein exiting the market. But there were other benefactors like Joom and like this really unfortunate thing: what I’m calling “fake heritage” brands.

00:20:10 - 00:20:31

Chris: Yeah, I love to call them like that. It’s a despicable, fraudulent business model.

Mike: This is the type of thing where, with Shein, Europe wanted to crack down on it. I understand why, but this is a business model that is much more resistant to that.

00:20:31 - 00:20:54

Mike: This is not a new category, but to summarize what one of these models is: they’ll have an innocuous, localized-sounding name like “Carlson Berlin”—that’s my favorite one to pick on right now—a “Berlin heritage store.”

00:20:54 - 00:21:22

Mike: I like to call them out because they advertise that they’ve been in business since 2001. They have an AI-generated image of the husband and wife founders in a shop in Berlin that doesn’t exist. Even if you put the image in Gemini, it has the SynthID baked into it. So it’s fake.

00:21:23 - 00:21:46

Mike: What they do is they’ll dropship a €6 shirt from China, put it on their website for €60, say that it’s marked down from €110, and there’s no mention of the tariff because their markup is so high that they can just eat it. So tariffs are not a very effective measure against these fraudulent businesses.

00:21:46 - 00:22:08

Mike: So they took a lot of Shein’s share. They had a dip after the tariffs landed, but it’s working for them. They’re much more prevalent now than they were before.

Chris: That’s why—maybe we can show the graph to our viewers here from the analysis you did—you see the golden line where they become a substantial player in the market.

00:22:09 - 00:22:34

Chris: It’s really fraudulent. My question would be: is it legally okay? There have to be some rules. You can’t just say there is an online shop in Berlin which doesn’t exist, fake the founder… I’m wondering why this is allowed to go on.

00:22:34 - 00:23:10

Mike: I don’t know where the line is, but I found hundreds of these in our Google Ads data. I think it’s partly a game of Whac-A-Mole. They are hard to detect. I think there is a common owner or a handful of common owners running all these shops through shell companies. They get flagged by review sites, but there are so many of them that you can’t distinguish them all.

00:23:10 - 00:23:28

Chris: We agreed not to be political in this podcast, by the way. I would love to be, but…

Mike: No, but this is where fairness comes into play. China just doesn’t give a fuck about that, because China could probably do something about it.

Chris: Or maybe not.

00:23:28 - 00:23:51

Chris: Some of these shell companies, if you go to the legal imprint page, have an owner listed in the US or somewhere in Europe. Maybe it’s Chinese, maybe it’s some asshole in the Netherlands doing it.

Mike: Yeah, it’s a wacky business.

00:23:51 - 00:24:19

Mike: Unfortunately, they disrupt the auction, and regular, honest businesses in Germany, Austria, Sweden—you name them—have to eat it and compensate for that.

Chris: In this case, as a buyer, you can act here. There could be some demand correction going on: do some research, and if you buy some product with a 50% discount from a shop you’ve never heard of, think twice.

00:24:19 - 00:24:48

Mike: A savvy buyer will recognize this, but unfortunately, not everyone is savvy.

Chris: And they also do tactics like heavily pushing you to buy multiples, because the tariff is paid per item. If you buy multiples, the tariff is spread against a larger basket. They have all these fake urgency tactics.

00:24:48 - 00:25:04

Mike: It’s crazy. But just to quickly sum it up: if we compare what happens if you land in the checkout of Shein, Joom, Temu, and Carlson Berlin: on Shein, you’re going to see the tariff disclosed, and you’re going to have to pay it, which is terrible for conversions.

00:25:04 - 00:25:26

Mike: If you are on Temu, you’ll see the same, but they’ve recently started subsidizing those. They’ll offer you a percentage off the tariff.

Chris: Discount on the tariff?

Mike: Yeah, a discount on the tariff! Which is insane, but for them, it’s going to have a positive effect on the conversion rate.

00:25:26 - 00:25:53

Mike: They must be thinking about elasticity and working this out. If you go to Joom, like Shein, you’ll see the tariff that you have to pay—which must be horrible for their conversion rate. Unlike Shein, they’re just running ads, and we don’t know how or why exactly.

00:25:53 - 00:26:16

Chris: By the way, there’s one operational ads KPI: they claim to have a global conversion rate of 2% to 3% overall for Joom. An overall conversion rate of 2% to 3% includes direct traffic, etc.

00:26:16 - 00:26:40

Mike: We could do some math here, but anyhow…

Chris: These fake heritage brands—they have a weird blend of slightly posh-looking elements and very obviously cheap AI elements. They are the biggest issue right now because it’s very hard to anticipate what they’re doing.

00:26:40 - 00:27:05

Mike: And you won’t see a tariff disclosed there at all because they want you to think you’re buying from Berlin. They just eat it.

Chris: But it’s going to take ten days for the product to arrive because it’s coming from China.

00:27:05 - 00:27:22

Mike: More awareness on the consumer side would help, indeed. Temu is coming back, unfortunately. Shein is still stuck in the mud. Let’s see what they will do in peak season, and let’s see how sustainable Joom is. They’re trying to defy gravity, but gravity still exists.

00:27:22 - 00:27:48

Chris: Gravity exists.

Mike: On that note, thank you Chris, and thank you everyone for listening. This has been another episode of Growing Ecommerce, brought to you, as always, by Smarter Ecommerce. See you next time!

00:27:48 - 00:28:02

Chris: Bye!

Mike: All right. ​​

Google Search logo
Add us as a preferred
source on Google →

Latest Episodes

Episode 60
Meta Muse’s First Numbers: Why Commissions Won’t Pay for It

Meta Muse’s First Numbers: Why Commissions Won’t Pay for It

Episode 58
Google’s August 17 Bidding Update: Good or Bad? The Data

Google’s August 17 Bidding Update: Good or Bad? The Data

Get the know-how directly to your inbox

Join our newsletter and be the first one to receive strategies and insights on the latest ecommerce & digital advertising trends.