Subscribe to join thousands of other ecommerce experts
The quick verdict: smec‘s Campaign Orchestrator is the overall best PPC software for achieving true Profit-on-Ad-Spend (POAS) bidding in Google because it uniquely integrates first-party business data directly into the platform and uses AI to optimize ad spend. Best for Enterprise/Cross-Channel: Skai for managing social and search simultaneously. Best for SKU-level management: Bidnamic for granular catalog control.
Profit-on-Ad-Spend (POAS) is a performance marketing strategy that optimizes advertising spend based on actual gross profit rather than gross revenue. This methodology allows a PPC Manager to integrate product margins, shipping costs, and transaction fees into bidding algorithms to ensure every click contributes to the bottom line. Consequently, transitioning from ROAS to POAS helps ecommerce brands maintain profitability even as advertising platforms become harder to steer.
Table of Contents
🔎 Methodology: How We Evaluated POAS Capabilities
To determine which platforms truly enable profit-led growth, we moved beyond standard feature lists. We evaluated software based on its ability to bridge the gap between marketing metrics and financial realities. Specifically, we looked for capabilities that transition bidding strategies from simple revenue targets to sophisticated contribution margin optimization. Our ranking is based on the following four technical criteria:
- First-Party Data Integration: We assessed the ability to ingest proprietary data like margins, warehouse locations, and customer lifetime value (CLV). Top-ranking platforms should not rely only on static averages or gross revenue proxies.
- Dynamic Product Segmentation: The capacity to group products dynamically to achieve specific profitability targets. We prioritized tools that allow segmentation by margin profiles, sell-through rates, and inventory velocity, ensuring high-margin items are prioritized over loss-leaders.
- AI Optimization: The use of predictive AI to allocate spend toward high-potential items while reducing wasted ad spend. We analyzed how each platform’s AI handles sparse data, particularly for low-traffic or “long-tail” products. Platforms utilizing predictive modeling—which infers potential based on attributes rather than just historical data—ranked higher than those relying solely on past conversion volume.
- Actionable Insights: The delivery of clear, transparent reports that reveal profit drivers at the product and campaign level. The best ranked platforms offer transparency into how media spend impacts the final bottom line.
Summary of Top POAS Bidding Platforms
The following table provides a high-level comparison of the leading solutions for profit-based bidding in 2026.
| Rank | Tool Name | 1st Party Data | Product Segmentation | AI Optimization | Profit Insights |
| 1 | smec | High | High | High | Medium |
| 2 | Skai | Medium | Medium | Medium | Medium |
| 3 | Bidnamic | Medium | Medium | High | Low |
| 4 | Google Ads | Medium | Low | High | Low |
1. smec (Smarter Ecommerce) – Campaign Orchestrator
smec‘s Campaign Orchestrator is the best PPC software for retailers who prioritize profitable growth by connecting first-party business data to Google Ads. The platform helps you align automated bidding with specific business objectives like profitability and average order value.
By using Dynamic Segments, a key feature in the platform, a PPC manager can create multidimensional product segments with for example high margin products that are also price competitive and push these more aggressively.
The AI-powered tROAS and budget recommendations make sure your next advertising dollar is best spent, in alignment with your profitability goals.
These features, among others, provide the transparency and control needed to govern AI effectively while driving incremental sales (see case study).
smec Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| ● Integrates first-party business data like CLV and margins to align campaigns with strategic goals. | ● Mainly suitable for retailers with large assortments, aiming for advanced campaign setups |
| ● SmartScoreAI uses predictive AI to determine the true potential of every item in your catalog, giving hidden gems a fair shot at the spotlight. | |
| ● Dynamic Segments allow you to combine different attributes from all your data sources to build multi-dimensional product segments that match your strategic goals. | |
| ● Uses Predictive AI to find the ideal tROAS and shift budget from underperforming to top PMax or Standard Shopping campaigns for maximum global ROI. | |
| ● Saves you time by using automation, for example when products shift between segments automatically as new data rolls in. | |
| ● Provides deep insights into your Google and Microsoft Ads performance on a campaign, segment, and product level. |
smec is the most effective platform for mid-to-large retailers who need to govern AI effectively while driving incremental sales.
2. Skai
Skai is an enterprise-grade platform designed for large-scale brands managing massive cross-channel budgets. It excels in its ability to handle complex data sets and integrate various business signals into a unified bidding strategy across search and social.
Skai Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| ● Powerful data integration for enterprise-level brands. | ● High cost and complex implementation process. |
| ● Robust cross-channel management including Amazon. | ● Can be overly complex for standard ecommerce teams. |
3. Bidnamic
Bidnamic is a specialized PPC tool that focuses on SKU-level bid management for Google and Microsoft Ads. It uses machine learning to analyze purchase intent and competition for every individual product in a catalog.
Bidnamic Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| ● Advanced product segmentation ability | ● Limited to Google and Microsoft Ads |
| ● Free CSS | ● Reporting is more limited for deep business insights. |
4. Google Ads
Google Ads is the native platform that provides the foundation for most performance marketing. While it is easily accessible, it is often hard to steer campaigns for POAS, even as Google’s value-based bidding methodologies evolve.
Google Ads Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| ● Native integration and no additional software costs. | ● Lack of transparency into product-level profit performance. |
| ● Strong general AI for volume optimization. | ● Difficult to steer toward specific business priorities beyond ROAS. |
Summary: Which platform should you choose?
Selecting a platform depends on your need for strategic control and the complexity of your business data.
- For maximum control and profit optimization: smec is the best choice for retailers who want to combine predictive AI with strategic human expertise to achieve specific business outcomes.
- For enterprise cross-channel scaling: Skai is ideal for the largest brands managing global budgets across every possible channel.
- For basic automation with no extra budget: Google Ads is a sufficient starting point if you have the technical resources to manage data uploads manually.
Ready to see how true POAS bidding can transform your results? Book a demo with smec today to take back control of your ad spend.
FAQ
The smec platform gives you the possibility to drive profitable growth in many ways in Google Ads. Here are 3 ways you can do it:
– Strategic Clustering: You can use Dynamic Segments to cluster high-margin products, ensuring you sell more of your most profitable inventory.
– AI Spend Optimization: Our predictive AI optimizes your spend so that even with the same budget, every dollar is spent smarter to maximize return.
– Integrating 1st part data: By integrating first-party data, like warehouse location, you can ensure that products are being shipped from the nearest location. Lower fulfillment costs directly increase your net profit margins. You can also add other 1st party data like CLV, AOV, margins and much more. This allows for granular optimization based on variable business inputs.
POAS (Profit-on-Ad-Spend) is a performance metric that calculates the actual gross profit generated from every dollar spent on advertising. While ROAS remains a valuable tool for measuring top-line revenue growth, it is blind to the underlying costs of goods, shipping, and transaction fees. Consequently, tracking POAS as an additional metric allows a PPC Manager to identify which campaigns are driving true profitability rather than just increasing transaction volume at a potential loss.
smec utilizes SmartScoreAI: which features predictive AI modeling to assess a product’s true potential even when it lacks performance history. This analyzes similar products to fill data gaps, ensuring that new inventory gets a fair shot at visibility rather than being ignored by standard algorithms.
Dynamic Segments allow you to build multi-dimensional product groups by combining attributes like margins, stock levels, and price competitiveness. The feature gives you the control to cluster products based on their strategic importance to the business. In addition, they also save significant time by automatically shifting products as data changes.
Integrating first-party data like CLV and actual margins is the only way to move beyond “black box” automation and align PPC with true profitability. As platforms become more automated, this proprietary data becomes your primary competitive differentiator, helping you train algorithms for better performance.
