Subscribe to join thousands of other ecommerce experts
In our PMax mistakes article we talked about the two biggest mistakes you can make in setting up your Performance Max campaigns. But how do you actually win in PMax? Y’know, it’s a bit like winning in pro-sports. You don’t just rely on star players (best-sellers) or trust your past performance to carry you across the finish line. You need to build a deep, balanced roster that can adapt to every game situation.
Table of Contents
🥈 The “okay-play”:
Knowing the basics
Let’s not get too ahead of ourselves, though! To stay in the game, you need to—at the very least—know the basics.
An “okay” PMax setup is when you segment products based on more than just one attribute. For example, you separate high-margin from low-margin products or break out best-sellers vs. new products.
Not only is this approach the bare minimum you need to stay competitive!, you’re also setting up a decent structure, allowing you to:
- Get some control over budget allocation – You can at least ensure high-margin or strategically important products get a decent slice of the budget.
- Create basic alignment with business goals – You’re no longer completely at the mercy of Google’s default settings.
BUT: Being basic is, well, “basic.”
It keeps you in the game, but it won’t win you the championship. You’re still at risk of:
- Falling into the “clicked vs. bought” trap – High-margin products might get clicks, but that doesn’t mean they convert.
- Overspending on safe bets – PMax might still pour budget into high-volume, low-margin items while your true profit drivers sit on the bench.
- Missing long-term opportunities – New, seasonal, or high-potential products might still struggle to get the attention they deserve.
TL;DR: If you want to make the playoffs, this is the bare minimum. But if you’re aiming to win the championship, you need tackle Google Ads on multiple fronts!
🥇 The winning play:
A multi-dimensional setup!
Great coaches don’t draft based on one stat—they analyze a mix of speed, endurance, and game intelligence.
Likewise, the best PMax setups don’t segment by just one or two factors. They use a multi-dimensional approach that considers profitability, demand trends, stock levels, and customer lifetime value (CLV):
- Look beyond the basics – Utilize multi-dimensional data points like CLV, AOV, demand trends, and inventory levels to identify products that truly align with your business goals.
- Play to strengths – Tailor separate PMax campaigns to specific product strengths. Use dedicated campaigns for high-margin items to boost profitability, seasonal products to capture demand, and new products to maximize visibility.
- Refine your strategy – Create separate asset groups or apply custom labels to ensure top performers don’t hog the budget, giving new, seasonal, and longtail products the visibility they need.
- Analyze the game tape – Use real performance data (beyond just ROAS) to fine-tune your strategy in real-time. Focus on profitability, AOV, and strategic business outcomes to keep PMax on track.
🏀 How the Miami HEAT keep their lineup balanced
Imagine the Miami HEAT only ever ran plays for Jimmy Butler, ignoring new talent and bench players. Sure, Jimmy might score a lot, but the team’s overall performance would suffer.
With PMax, it’s the same. The Miami HEAT used this multi-dimensional strategy and achieved impressive results, both on and off the court. They:
- Segmented products strategically, focusing on entry products (e.g., affordable merchandise to attract new fans) and high-margin items to boost profitability.
- Dynamically re-scored products daily, allowing campaigns to adapt quickly to seasonality, team performance, and market trends.
- Balanced their ad spend by assigning priority scores to products, ensuring star products drew in traffic while also supporting long-term business goals.
This approach helped the HEAT boost their revenue by +70% and drive 55% more conversions! Proving that a data-driven, balanced approach beats a one-dimensional strategy—every time.
🛑 ‘Set-it-and-forget-it’ won’t cut it!
Creating the winning PMax strategy means going beyond the basics!
You need to integrate smarter data like profit margins, inventory levels, and customer lifetime value to give Google’s AI the right guidance.
But knowing what to fix is only half the battle.
👉 Check out our Ultimate PMax Optimization Playbook for a step-by-step guide on building campaigns that align with your business goals and deliver real results:
